DM-03 | The Ol' Ivy Retcon
Download MP3Adam "Bridger" Ruzzo (00:00)
So Brian, I don't know if this is anything, but Ivy chose the ancient ways the for the duel between Harry and Ortega. Should we come up with like what it what would it look like if she chose the modern ways?
Brian (00:13)
Well, I mean, presumably that is an option, right? She says she's choosing it, so there's gotta be some alternative. So that makes sense, but like
Adam "Bridger" Ruzzo (00:21)
Well, yeah.
Brian (00:22)
what do is there anything that stands out? Like what would the modern ways be?
Adam "Bridger" Ruzzo (00:26)
Well, it's gotta be four things, right? It's gotta match those other ones. So maybe the first one could be some kind of sport like like thinking about a duel, like fencing, right?
Brian (00:34)
Okay. That's not really modern. Like that's that's been around for I mean, I don't know how long, but like, had to be something like MMA, you know, something like modern. Yeah, yeah, yeah.
Adam "Bridger" Ruzzo (00:44)
okay, yeah. Mixed martial arts, okay. Um,
and then w we could do something like uh running a marathon.
Brian (00:50)
Yeah, that's not modern either. We're we're kind of just going in circles here. oh, I got it. Going in circles. NASCAR racing.
Adam "Bridger" Ruzzo (00:57)
Oh yes, because there does have to be something on the list that Harry would absolutely lose at. okay, I got it. Number three,
war.
Brian (01:05)
There's t like the card game, there's two of them.
Adam "Bridger" Ruzzo (01:07)
No, not the card game.
Brian (01:09)
I mean that would be appropriate. So okay, what's what's the last one then?
Adam "Bridger" Ruzzo (01:13)
I don't know, but it's gotta be okay. Huh. Super Smash Brothers Melee.
Brian (01:18)
No items, fox only, final destination.
Adam "Bridger" Ruzzo (01:29)
Welcome one, welcome all, welcome to Recorded Neutral Territory where the spoilers go all the way through twelve months. I'm Adam Ruzzo and with me as always it's the world's second best canine themed hitman. It's Brian O'Reilly.
Brian (01:43)
They call me the heck hound. Kinkada always gets the best assassination contracts, but I don't have to babysit anyway.
Adam "Bridger" Ruzzo (01:53)
that is a nice fringe benefit. All right, Brian, today we are talking about chapters eight, nine, ten, and eleven. This is where Harry talks with Bob about the case, calls up Alshara Vas, the Oracle Spirit, for some help. He has he does a lot of phone calls actually in this, because he also calls with Ebenezer and then he meets the archive for the first time.
Brian (02:15)
Yeah. And it ends on that phone call to Michael, so it's sort of like these are the chapters of the phone calls in the book. But just to give a big picture overview, so Harry goes over the rules for dueling with Bob, discusses the plague curse with Bob, talks about the Denarians and the Shroud with Bob, and then lets Bob out and consults Ul Sharavas.
Adam "Bridger" Ruzzo (02:37)
Yeah, Ulsharavas is the I think only the second time we've seen Harry actually do a summoning so far in the book series. And she's described as an ally of the Loa and an Oracle spirit. So I thought that it might make sense to ste step aside and and talk about the Loa a little bit. the Loa are spirits out of Haitian voodoo.
And there are apparently thousands of them, and they act as an intermediary between humans and the voodoo creator deity named Bandi. And that kind of sounds like they serve a similar function to angels, though obviously not identical. They can offer help, protection, and counsel to humans in return for ritual service. This sounds like a more interventionist role than actually angels do in the Christian doctrine.
And the Loa can either be loyal or capricious, which Bob does warn Harry, hey, she's not normally malicious. And Harry's like, normally. then we also get that Voodooists believe that the Loa are easily offended, which means Harry, find something better than a cabbage patch doll. He's he's lucky that he didn't actually offend her that much here.
Brian (03:45)
Yeah, he
didn't get one that was very persticity, exactly.
Adam "Bridger" Ruzzo (03:48)
Yeah.
voodooists also believe that the Loa communicate with humans through dreams and through the possession of human beings, or in this case, a human like object. There are differences here, but remember, Jim specifically wrote that she is an ally of the Loa. she's associated with but not specifically a Loa.
Brian (04:07)
Right. And I think part of
why it's important to note that, Adam, is that I think Jim is very smartly realizing that there's a lot of different people with a lot of different interpretations of exactly what voodoo is.
Adam "Bridger" Ruzzo (04:19)
Mm-hmm.
Brian (04:20)
And if I say this is what the Loa are like, I might piss off a lot of people. So if I make her something like a Loa, well, I can borrow from those tropes, but it's okay that she's not going to use all of them. So I think it's really good to rehash this because Jim is
Like deliberately not making her a Loa, but he's signaling to us, this is where I'm pulling from.
Adam "Bridger" Ruzzo (04:42)
Exactly. So let's talk about what she actually does here with Harry, right? He's calling her up and he's asking for information about the shroud. Actually, he doesn't even ask. She just says, You're looking for information about the shroud, right? the price that she asks for this information is the answer to one question. And the question is, why do you do what you do? So first, Brian.
why is it this her price? is this valuable to her in some way?
Brian (05:13)
So I think there's two ways to look at this because it's definitely valuable to Harry, right? Harry thinking about this at this moment when he's going into conflict against, somebody who is a tempter who's gonna try to seduce him to evil. Why do you do what you do? Really, really good time to remind him of that. So one reason that might be her price.
Is because Olsharavis really isn't that neutral. She's trying to help.
Adam "Bridger" Ruzzo (05:42)
Yeah, and I think there's a couple of different flavors of ways to explain what she's trying to help with. And the first one is a result of the specific way she responds to his final answer, right? She says, Why do you help other mortals as you do? And he thinks about it for a while and then eventually says
I don't know. I guess I never thought about it all that much. And her response is, don't you think you should? And that seems like a weird response, right? As if she was expecting that response and is trying to get across some communicate something to him, right? And there is a hypothesis out there based in part on a line from Blood Rites that we're gonna get to next book, where
Harry asks Kincaid if he's human, and Kincaid answers, as human as you are, Dresden, and we know that Kincaid is a scion of something from hell, essentially, right? So does that mean that Harry is also a scion? That is what kind of spawned or sparked or gave weight to this hypothesis that Harry might be a scion of something, and some people think he's a scion of something celestial.
Brian (06:56)
Yeah, and that is um sort of the the Nephilim theory. Uh the Red Moses or Moses the Red has a lot of posts about it. it's an interesting theory because Jim has already signals he's he's pulling from that source material. Mac as a watcher is almost certainly a reference to the Gregori, who are the angels in the book of Enoch, where, you know, the beings that are these
Adam "Bridger" Ruzzo (07:20)
Not
not the blue guys from Marvel?
Brian (07:22)
No, not the blue guys from Marvel. Yeah, easy to confuse them. No. But
Adam "Bridger" Ruzzo (07:25)
Oh, okay.
Brian (07:26)
or the civilization from Civ 4 Fall from Heaven.
but Jim is definitely touching on the stuff that's from Christian Apocrypha, not just the actual Bible.
it's possible that.
building up to an eventual revelation of this kind that's on Jim's mind when he's writing these books with Kincaid in them. he wants to lay the groundwork for Harry thinking about who he is, what he is, what his nature is. It's in his nature to help people. He doesn't even think about it. It's just what he does. You that could be because he's just not like your average Joe.
Adam "Bridger" Ruzzo (08:05)
Yeah, the implication being there's a reason you do what you do, and it's not just because your dad raised you up to be a nice guy and you were beat up by bullies, so you don't like bullies, right? That's the assumption we make is our hero a had a some kind of a childhood with a mentor figure and or uh was a victim of something that taught him to fight bullies. That's kind of the way it's presented to us. That's the obvious explanation, but this seemed to hint that there was something
Beneath that, something deeper.
Brian (08:36)
And one of the reasons why Jim might be thinking about that when he's writing this book is because up against the Denarians.
Why is Nicodemus targeting him? Maybe because Nicodemus is the kind of person who looks for people who fit, Scion of Heaven or Hell, check that's one point on my bingo card. But I don't think that's necessarily true, Adam. In fact, I would suggest that it's probably simpler than that.
Adam "Bridger" Ruzzo (09:03)
Yeah, I agree. I don't think it's the most likely answer. To me, what this feels like is maybe this is just getting Harry to think a little bit more about why he does what he does. Because introspection can help temper an otherwise impulsive nature. And Harry is a little impulsive. He's a little reckless, especially when, people are in danger. So it seems to me that if you're going to
prod him back onto the right path. you're an Oracle spirit, right? So she can kind of see different versions of the future. Maybe there's like he might be veering in the wrong direction. And it's just like, just give him a little prod. Make him think about and remind him why he does what he does. That is just enough to nudge him back on the right path. And this might be the same thing, right? An asteroid coming towards the Earth, if you give it a very small nudge,
hundreds and hundreds of thousands of miles away, it's gonna miss the earth by a huge margin. So maybe this is avoiding something that's seven books from now that we don't we we couldn't even necessarily think of. But just this little gentle nudge could be enough to help.
Brian (10:11)
Yeah, and I think that the really interesting thing about that is in this book, there's a lot of decisions that Harry could make that would be totally, you know, in concert with who he is in some ways, that would be horrible decisions, right? So we're gonna talk about Susan later, but Harry basically threads the needle on that one as close to the edges as he possibly could.
Adam "Bridger" Ruzzo (10:36)
Mm-hmm.
Brian (10:36)
He could take up the coin. I mean, he literally does pick it up at the end of this book. He didn't have to. It's very tempting for him, subconsciously. Jim is like very strongly signaling that. And reminding Harry that he's not that kind of person is very important. And also, there's the red court plot. Look, Harry could turn down this duel. The next chapter, Ebenezer is gonna say, Hey, don't worry about it, man. We'll get you out of this.
And he could also try to cheat. Now cheating's gonna happen anyway, but it's not Harry doing it. And
Adam "Bridger" Ruzzo (11:12)
And Ortega's
gonna offer him, hey, just join us. That'll end the duel too. And then your friends
Brian (11:16)
Right.
Adam "Bridger" Ruzzo (11:18)
don't have to get hurt.
Brian (11:19)
and maybe that's against Harry's nature, but you know, burn the house down around Ortega, that's perfectly with he has already done that to a house full of vampires.
Adam "Bridger" Ruzzo (11:27)
Yeah.
Brian (11:28)
But that's the kind of impulsive choice that leads towards black magic. So keeping Harry, true to his principles, true to his beliefs, true to his faith in the proper use of magic and
Magic restrained by human will to help people, really, really important, from a spirit that seems to be faith-based. But Adam, I think that there could be a way that this is just straight up valuable to Ulsharavas in the first place. Ulsharavas wants to know why Harry does what Harry does, because Ulsharavas has friends. And those friends, every time one of these cycles comes around, they gotta figure out where to hide.
They gotta figure out where ground zero is gonna be, and they gotta figure out how not to be there. They've gotta line stuff up so that the big moves and shakes in the supernatural world don't bulldoze them. Or they've gotta figure out what horses they're gonna back to save the world from outsider incursions. And this is the part of the game where you figure out who the potential starborn are and which ones are worth backing. Harry
Adam "Bridger" Ruzzo (12:37)
Yeah.
Brian (12:38)
gives an answer to this that.
Doesn't make him seem necessarily like, he's your favorite person ever and this is clearly the protagonist of this larger story, but it doesn't disqualify him either. That's important information.
Adam "Bridger" Ruzzo (12:52)
Agreed. And the way that it's actually written is when Harry gives that answer, we get, quote, the doll watched me with unnerving intensity for a full minute before nodding. Don't you think you should? Unquote. Watching for a full minute and just processing that answer does suggest that it had value. But the other way to read it is, of course, okay, based on that answer, what answer do I need to give back?
to nudge things in the right way. So you could read that in both directions.
Brian (13:23)
Yeah, it's definitely a long enough pause. And Jim does this sometimes where he says a full minute when he probably should just say a moment. But
Adam "Bridger" Ruzzo (13:30)
Yeah.
Brian (13:30)
if we do take it literally here, that is a pause where you can almost feel, oh, she's looking into the future. So, okay,
Adam "Bridger" Ruzzo (13:38)
Yeah, seems like it.
Brian (13:40)
that question I think we've handled, but it seems like Olsharavas is trying to help Harry to restore balance.
in this confrontation between the white god and the Darians.
Adam "Bridger" Ruzzo (13:54)
Yeah, I mean, at the end of this conversation, she points out that his friends, the knights, received part of a prophecy. The other part of the prophecy was blocked by the adversary, presumably referring to the Nicodemus, Denarians, forces from hell, whatever you want to call it.
Brian (14:11)
Or literally, I mean the adversary is an he who walks beside and
we can't remember because Jesus Christ, Jim is using this name so on purpose, it's also the literal translation of Satan.
Adam "Bridger" Ruzzo (14:23)
wow, yeah, okay. So yeah, and their capital A adversary, by the way. It is capitalized. So there is some specific meaning to it. But anyway, their adversary concealed some of it from them is the way that it's actually written here. And Harry asks, Why are you telling me this? And Ulsharavas says, Because you must hear the second half of the prophecy in order to restore the balance. So obviously balance is important to Al Sharavas. The question is
Why? Well, we know that she is an ally of the Loa. They are sort of, again, filling some kind of role similar to angels talking between God and and man. And we know that angels, with when it comes to the white god, are very interested in balance. It's literally the only place they're allowed to act is when they're restoring balance because the other side cheated more or less. And that
also makes me think, Brian, what if this is Uriel either in disguise or working through this Oracle spirit?
Brian (15:28)
So there's no reason that Uriel couldn't have multiple names. Odin has a ton of things you could call him by, and when you call him by different names, he comes in different guises. So not weird that you could call up Uriel by another name and he'd play a different role and you know, whatever. Now, I don't think that's the case here, because I think that Jim is invoking the Loa.
To invoke the idea of a spirit that is aligned with the spiritual, the divine world that isn't an archangel. Like he could just have this be and then an archangel appeared to Harry and said, No, that doesn't necessarily work as well in this book, but he could do that. I think he's deliberately avoiding that so that it remains more grounded. So
It sort of undercuts what's happening here if it's Uriel, but it certainly could be. I mean, that there's no reason why it couldn't be.
Adam "Bridger" Ruzzo (16:29)
Yeah, and I guess the other possibility here is we know that Haitian voodoo arose through a process of syncretism between sort of West and Central African religions as well as Catholicism. They sort of mixed together in uh in Haiti and created what is now known as Haitian voodoo. So there are aspects of Catholicism built into that. So maybe
the Haitian god Banji and the white god are actually one and the same. They're both talking about and worshiping the same thing, just giving different names. And there's some consideration to be made for that just without throughout the Dresden Files itself.
Brian (17:13)
Yeah, we're not gonna go into a lot of detail on this, but it's not inconsistent to see the Loa as like a kind of angel, right? And that doesn't mean they're like Uriel or even, you know, like the angel of death Dresden's gonna see in Ghost Story or like some lesser angel. the Bible has and and forget about the Bible, but Gnosticism has whole classifications of different kinds of angels. So
Adam "Bridger" Ruzzo (17:39)
Mm-hmm.
Brian (17:40)
if you think of a Loa as like
The least of them, you know, the sort of the the or not Aloa, but if you think of Ulsharavas as like the least angel in this larger white god organization, then I think that kind of makes sense. That, she is a servant of the white god who's sort of running the help desk for the Haitian voodoo version of their hotline.
Adam "Bridger" Ruzzo (18:06)
Ha yeah.
Brian (18:07)
But
It's also possible that Olsharavas wants to restore balance because she isn't a servant of the white god. She isn't a servant of the devil. She is, as Harry calls himself, theological Switzerland. And what does Switzerland want? Balance. Because even if the good guys are winning, right? Like World War One.
Even if you're pro-democracy and you want the democracies to win. Well, if they win by too much, you get a Treaty of Versailles, and if you get a Treaty of Versailles, a lot of bad things happen. So it could be the case that Oracle spirits in general, who are very concerned with the future consequences of the things that are happening in the here and now, and the large effects of changes on the future, might want things to not have radical changes, to go on their sort of
natural course to not deviate into uh futures that are very extreme one way or another, and she would help the Denarians if the knights had a huge advantage over them, because what Ulsharavas really wants out of this is to make sure that Harry does what he's kind of metaphysically supposed to do, that
Things don't go crazy. Like with a plague that cills ninety percent of humanity.
Adam "Bridger" Ruzzo (19:32)
Yeah. Now, she's extra helpful here. Right at the end of all this, she just says, Yeah, not only am I giving you the exact place where the shroud is, it's on a small craft in the marina named the Etrange. There you go. Perfect. That's exactly where you need to go. Also, here's the prophecy your friends heard. It's incomplete. Here's the rest of the information. It's just like boom, big bang. It didn't cost you anything but a little you're out of Prince Albert in a can, but aside from that
You you got
Brian (20:00)
Right.
Adam "Bridger" Ruzzo (20:00)
away without giving away anything like your your your name to Chauncey. So why wouldn't Harry just call up this Oracle spirit for every one of the cases going forward?
Brian (20:10)
yeah, well, I think one obvious thing is that Harry does a lot of summoning between sixteen, when he sends spirits all over to track down Elaine, and, full moon, when Chauncey's got three of his names already. And after Chauncey
basically exposes his true nature trying to get that fourth name out of Harry in that conversation where he's gotten the third.
Adam "Bridger" Ruzzo (20:36)
Mm-hmm.
Brian (20:36)
I think Harry says, Holy hell. I thought I was playing with fire. Turns out I really was.
Adam "Bridger" Ruzzo (20:43)
Yeah, no, it's
not just fire. This is a Yeah, hellfire. Exactly.
Brian (20:45)
It's it's Hellfire specifically, right? So
so the fact that like it's it got that real for him in that moment has made Harry generally gun shy about calling up spirits, and the only reason he calls this one is because Bob is like, I'm not gonna help you. You specifically need to phone a friend. Here's your lifeline.
Adam "Bridger" Ruzzo (21:06)
Yeah, yeah, we didn't talk
about it, but earlier in this in this chapter, Bob says, I can't touch it. It exists on a different wavelength as me. It's out of my jurisdiction. And even if he tries, he'll be crossing boundaries he shouldn't. And he says, I'm not going up against Angels Dresden, fallen or otherwise. That's a great line. But it also, yeah, if Harry can't call up Bob to give him some basic help on this, and Bob then
recommends a specific one. Like something tells me Bob didn't recommend Chauncey. He probably
Brian (21:42)
Right.
Adam "Bridger" Ruzzo (21:42)
counseled against it and Harry did it anyway.
Brian (21:46)
Or, you know, Bob said, Well yeah, Chauncey has great information. You know, you can see here in the grimoire that it says he's very dangerous, but you know, hell also their information is good. Like whereas here he's like Dresden, this is who you gotta call. Very, very specific, a lot more direct, not yeah.
Adam "Bridger" Ruzzo (22:00)
Yeah, just a stronger recommendation from Bob
does sort of make sense here.
Brian (22:04)
And we don't know, Adam, that he never calls her up. He probably calls her up during changes.
Adam "Bridger" Ruzzo (22:11)
yeah, 'cause he got very desperate when he's looking for Maggie and he off page basically describes how he called up a bunch of beings, but none of them had the information that he wanted. And I think he called up Ivy after that, and he was going to go to what was it, his blue binder, and Ivy says, Do not open your blue binder. Like she knows what's in there and it's gonna go real bad. So we're gonna have some fun talking about that when we get to changes. But you're right. It's entirely possible he called her up, but like, what is a
divinity like deity ha she's not gonna help him find his daughter. It doesn't have anything to do with faith at all.
Brian (22:44)
Ulsharavas told him that he needs to talk to the archive, and you know, Harry being stubborn then proceeded to, con contact a whole bunch of other spirits because he wanted to make sure Ivy knew that he really did try everything before he
Adam "Bridger" Ruzzo (22:57)
Yeah, it could be that. So okay. The next thing I want to talk about here, Brian, is because Osharavas has delivered this prophecy to Harry. We see it. And the prophecy says, quote
Should you seek the shroud, Harry Dresden, you will most assuredly perish, and if you do not, they all die and this city with them, unquote.
Brian (23:19)
Okay,
wait a second, Adam, I literally am paid to teach logic, so I will work this one out, I can figure this prophecy out. So what they're saying is if Harry doesn't seek the shroud, City is destroyed.
Adam "Bridger" Ruzzo (23:32)
Mm-hmm.
Brian (23:32)
So Harry clearly he sought the shroud.
Adam "Bridger" Ruzzo (23:35)
Yeah, we saw in the book that he sought the shroud.
Brian (23:37)
Right, okay. So therefore, end of series how addressed instead.
Adam "Bridger" Ruzzo (23:40)
Yeah, that is one possibility because it doesn't say you will s most assuredly perish in your attempt to seek the shroud or in the next week. It just says you'll definitely die at some point, unspecified. So the but seriously here, it is a little I mean Harry takes it to mean he will die in the process of fine of searching for the shroud, and I think that's the intended meaning here. So let's talk about it in that context.
We know that Harry doesn't die in this book. So does that mean that prophecies are bunk in the Dresden files? They're just wrong some of the time?
Brian (24:16)
So part of why I was trying to bring that up is because I think Jim is subscribing to the ch the school of prophecy that is essentially very exact words and also this prophecy it not just that prophecies are true, you know, to their exact words, but also that prophecies are not necessarily
the truth, even if they're true. By which I mean if you prophesyze, if you throw that ball into the cup, you your friend will have to drink the beer because you're playing beer pong. That could be a prophecy. But what actually might happen is if you throw the ball into the cup, the cup is gonna get knocked over and that's going to
cause somebody to slip, which is gonna cause them to crack their head and die. And like the prophecy isn't necessarily telling you the most important event that's going to result from, the the circumstances that you're engaged in, because in the Dresden Files, prophecy, like intellectus,
It's an answer to a specific question. It is not a message designed to give you the most important information. So this prophecy, on the one hand, we can say, well, if you say that seeking the shroud will kill Harry Dresden, that's just wrong. It might not be wrong.
It might be a future Olsharavas has seen, but not the only possible one, just the only one her questions could lead her to.
Adam "Bridger" Ruzzo (25:59)
Yeah, mean Harry in the next chapter will describe the prophecy processes. These spirits exist in both the future and the past. And Sharavas almost certainly wasn't the one who actually made the prophecy, right? It could be, but it seems unlikely that that is necessarily the case. But in in whatever did make the prophecy
There could be some leaps of logic there because we know later in this book, when Shiro is dying and Harry gets there at the at the airport, Michael explains
The noose around Nicodemus' neck has the power to essentially fate someone to die once per year. That's the ability it has. And it's called
The Barabbas curse. And
We know that he interprets this to mean, oh, that entropy curse that was coming at me and Susan before we had to hide under the wards. And Shiro and Michael then explain that the curse cannot be stopped, but we, presumably meaning the knights, can take the place of the person that was attacked. So the way that I see this, Brian, is that the
Prophecy, the oracle spirit, whatever it was that made the prophecy, the seer, saw that the Barabas curse was sent after Dresden. And they're like, well, that's it. That's game over. Because that means he has to die. Death is coming for him. It's inevitable. And gave the prophecy based on that data, but didn't account for the fact that Shiro was going to make the choice.
to sacrifice himself in Harry's place.
Brian (27:39)
Right. Well, it also might be that when you look into the future, you can only base your future analysis off of events that have happened.
Adam "Bridger" Ruzzo (27:50)
Hm.
Brian (27:50)
So what I mean by this is if you look into the future at the moment where the prophecy is revealed, Shiro's not gonna sacrifice himself for Harry. Like Shiro, the Shiro of that moment, is not necessarily motivated to
you know, give up his life because Nicodemus is laying out the Barabbas curse on him.
Adam "Bridger" Ruzzo (28:10)
But then
he meets Harry and that changes things.
Brian (28:13)
And
and not just that, Adam, it's a very specific series of events where only because Michael and Sonia are in St. Louis on a different mission, and Shiro asks Charity, would your husband help this man? And Charity answers honestly, you know, yes, you know, Michael thinks that he's a good man and all that stuff. Like it's only because of this very specific series of events.
That Shiro decides, you know what? This guy is really worth preserving. I would be willing to uh lay down my life to submit myself to torture in order to ensure that. And that's not something that this Oracle spirit necessarily could have predicted. That Shiro would have been that invested in Dresden that quickly on the basis of the information they had at the time. So I think there's a lot of ways that you can look at this where.
It it's like when they're looking into the future, they're almost like a wizard casting a spell, accounting for certain variables and sort of running the equation forward. And what they're seeing is something that could happen, but if they haven't accounted for the ability of certain things to change, it might not be the only possible future.
What I mean is that in the Dresden Files, free will can be something that is, inevitably exercised in one direction on the basis of your character. That is, repa these events a hundred times and Shiro will make the same choice every time. And also, which you couldn't possibly predict beforehand, because no one could predict the exact circumstances that would lead someone like Shiro.
exercise his free will in a given moment. I know that's really complicated, but Jim, as soon as he brings into this story the idea of prophecy, creates this very, very thorny set of issues about what prophecy does and how free will works in the Dresden Files. So I think it's just worth considering why this prophecy on the surface just seems wrong, just completely wrong.
Adam "Bridger" Ruzzo (30:25)
Yeah, and that's one of the reasons that Harry says, I don't put much stock in prophecy. As extensive and aware as these spirits might be, they aren't all knowing. And as nutty as people are, I don't buy that any spirit is gonna be able to keep an absolute lock on every possible temporal outcome. Unquote. So that does help muddy the waters a little bit for Jim, right? To have Harry say, Eh they're not always right. So this is just an example of that probably. Now
The next chapter we have Harry brewing up a red court anti venom potion that's gonna be, of course, like most potions, the checkoffs potion, when's he gonna use this? Turns out it's gonna be for fun handcuffed time with Susan, as we're going to find out in a future chapter. But one of the things, Brian, that has to go into this potion, in addition to stale coffee, because it has to be the opposite of the awesome euphoric high of vampire venom.
Is a small photo of meatloaf cut from a magazine for sight. And that is capital capital L meaning the the singer, the musician, not the food. Right?
Brian (31:25)
Yeah, t not the food, which almost makes more sense. Yeah.
Adam "Bridger" Ruzzo (31:29)
And he just had one of those lying around in one of these tubs. Like, oh, I'm gonna need something absolutely disgusting to look at. Ah, here we go. Meatloaf. Let me just put this in my disgusting to look at box.
Brian (31:44)
Yeah, it's some real shade thrown at the poor guy. I will say
Adam "Bridger" Ruzzo (31:47)
Ha ha ha.
Brian (31:47)
there's two possibilities here that I can think of. One, he needs a a potion that would ruin the pleasurable sensations of the poison. Harry just doesn't like, like it's specifically the narcotic effect is an arousing one.
Adam "Bridger" Ruzzo (32:05)
Yes.
Brian (32:05)
Like Meatloaf is just, you know, for Dresden.
sort of an overweight man is the least attractive, like sexually, you know. But I think another possibility is that Harry doesn't have a picture of meatloaf lying around because he's like, in case I need a picture of an unattractive guy, you know, I've always got this meatloaf one. It's that Harry goes, I need a picture of somebody who I don't think is sexy. Where the hell could I get that? You know, I don't get Cosmo.
And he happens to have a rolling stone with Mifloaf on it, you know, somewhere.
Adam "Bridger" Ruzzo (32:36)
Sure. Yeah, yeah, yeah.
Entirely possible. Okay, so the next thing that happens after he starts making this potion is Ebenezer calls and he says, Don't worry about this Ortega thing, Hoss. We'll take care of it. And Harry says, No, I gotta do it or he's gonna kill all my friends And Ebenezer's like, All right, as long as you know what you're doing. But then there's this small back and forth where Ebenezer says, Hey, you remember
that telescope that we that we had and we get this little reminisce about how they found what they thought was an asteroid and they named it after him and he's like asteroid Dresden was a much better name than Cosmos five because it turned out to be a Russian satellite. Brian, why is Ebenezer asking him about this telescope and does it have anything to do with what happens at the end of this book?
Brian (33:20)
It certainly has to do with what happens at the end of this book. I think that Ebenezer's reminding Harry of this because as the blackstaff, he can't tell anyone when he puts on the black hat and does the wet works. But without breaching that confidentiality.
He wants Dresden to know that he, Ebenezer, is specifically protecting him. And Ebenezer is already thinking, yeah, yeah, whatever you say, Haas, I'm gonna drop a satellite on this guy.
Adam "Bridger" Ruzzo (33:58)
Yeah. I
think he might be preparing for that eventuality, right? If this guy kills my grandson, I wanna be ready for him.
Brian (34:05)
But see, there's no point to remind Harry if you're only gonna do it when Harry dies.
Adam "Bridger" Ruzzo (34:07)
I don't think he's reminding
Harry. I think he's literally looking for the telescope because he's like, I need this in order to see the target.
Brian (34:13)
Yeah, that's definitely one possibility that Dresden brings up the asteroid
which is not what Ebenezer is trying to do. Ebenezer's already thought of the asteroid. He's just trying to find the telescope so he can find the satellite that's in space.
Adam "Bridger" Ruzzo (34:23)
Yeah, and the observation logs he asks for. So he's
I think he's prepping and it's like a line of sight thing. I can only bring this thing down on my enemy if I can see it.
Brian (34:32)
I wonder if Ebenezer because here's the thing that I don't get in this scene.
Dresden's like, no, Ebenezer, I I'm gonna have to take him. And Ebenezer's like, okay, Haas, if that's what you want. I feel like, given Ebenezer's later actions, he would try to dissuade Dresden a little bit more strongly
the way that he casually just lets Dresden, from Ebenezer's perspective, seemingly throw his life away in a duel against Ortega me makes me think that Ebenezer has no actual intention of letting it happen.
Adam "Bridger" Ruzzo (35:08)
Yeah, there's that as a possibility, but the other thing that's always struck me is really odd when you find out that Ebenezer is his grandfather, and all those times that he just let Harry go into incredible danger and take enormous risks and didn't come to really try and help at all. This is just one example of those. It makes me think like
Why he appears to care so much for him, but he du he lets him do crazy reckless things without any kind of even support. And that made me think, why? Why would that be the case? And then I remembered that the reason that his daughter got estranged from him, Harry's mother, is because Ebenezer tried to hold on too tight. He tried to train her himself.
She was his apprentice. And I think when she started to make choices that he didn't like, he got angry and he got forceful and he insisted if you're under my roof, then you're gonna do things my way. And that's when she said, Well, then I guess I'm not gonna live under your roof again. And she left. And he's trying to not make that mistake, but I think he's overcorrecting, right? In the other direction. He's trying to be like
I can't get any more hands on because I don't want to risk losing the relationship I do have. He doesn't even know he's my grandson. If I try to tell him what to do, I know how stubborn he is. He will push me away and then I'll have no control. Right. So I think that might be what's happening with Evan Ezer here.
Brian (36:41)
Right, real second child syndrome, where with the first kid you try to make them do everything right, and with the second kid you're just like, Ah fuck it, I'm tired.
Adam "Bridger" Ruzzo (36:50)
Yeah. Exactly. So my other answer to this, the we talked about the Watsonian answer, right? What is why is Ebenezer asking about this telescope in this particular way? Is it 'cause he's planning for what's happening later, is it just a coincidence? Whatever. But I think the Doyleist answer here is that Jim really wants to put this exposition in here so that at the end it feels like a great payoff to this little moment instead of a
Dez Ex Makina. Oh, by the way, there was an old Soviet satellite that Dresden and Ebenezer happened to have seen a long time ago, and that's what felt it it's much more appropriate to put in a little bit of detail here.
Brian (37:28)
Yes, he needs to do this because if this really does come out of nowhere, it seems like one of those ridiculous ass pulls that just destroys verisimilitude. Like, okay, so orbital drop satellite is just you can do that when you're mad,
and the funny thing is, you know, Ebenezer could pull down any number of satellites. Theoretically, he doesn't need to ask Dresden about this one. He could do whatever. So Jim's setting this up is specifically to kind of give it a cause and effect feel. Like, well, they can use this one because in some ways it's their satellite. And that doesn't actually matter. But as a reader, it feels like it does. So he has to put it in.
Adam "Bridger" Ruzzo (38:13)
Yeah, absolutely. Now, after this phone call with Ebenezer, Bob returns severely injured from walking into Marcone's wards, and he gives his report to Dresden. He found Ortega at the Rothschild and he couldn't tell who made the wards on Marcone. They were too good, and then he just goes to sleep. Harry's like, go to bed, we'll talk later. Then the ward flames start going crazy big. Like the flame is as big and tall as his head.
And Harry's like, oh shit, and he goes to gear up. And the next chapter, chapter ten, turns out to be Kincaid at his doorstep and Ivy not far behind.
Brian (38:51)
It's such like a triple fake out because you first assume whatever set up the words for Marcone. It's coming, it's followed him back. You
Adam "Bridger" Ruzzo (39:00)
Yes.
Brian (39:00)
know, it's a nightmare scenario. Like literally, like a like the nightmare. Not
Adam "Bridger" Ruzzo (39:04)
Yeah.
Brian (39:04)
a nightmare scenario. The nightmare scenario. And then, oh, Kincaid's at the door. So it was him. No, it's this creepy ass six year old girl.
Adam "Bridger" Ruzzo (39:16)
Yeah.
Brian (39:17)
Just really, you know, I I really love the archivist character and what a way to introduce her.
Adam "Bridger" Ruzzo (39:23)
Yeah, we and this is just after sunrise, by the way. Bob only just made it home before the sunrise came up. So Archive is showing up. It's dawn, and of course Harry gets all belted up with a gun and it impresses Kincaid. He's he says, haven't seen any of council's people carry a gun. Good for you. This shouldn't take long. And then the IV comes down, he gives her a name, and we get to some
Expositing from the archive about what she is, right? Harry has never heard of the archive before, which makes sense. You probably don't wanna go around announcing your presence to every random supernatural community member. Of course, the big name people, right? The senior council, the the Denarians, like all the people that sign the accords, they know the other accorded nations. She's an emissary. So like on the diplomacy stage, she's known, but she's not gonna announce herself and she's not
People aren't gonna talk about the existence of the archive in their social circles.
Brian (40:20)
Yeah, I also think telling a wizard apprentice about the existence of the archive, it's like telling somebody with a very niche spence special interest that you built an AI just about that. Like that's all they're gonna be doing for the next forever. As soon as you tell a young wizard apprentice, Yeah, well, you know, there's exists a being that's the repository of all written knowledge.
You know, the archive's just getting nothing but people writing letters to the archive. Right? So it's just it's right. And and and
Adam "Bridger" Ruzzo (40:52)
uh Oh no, I didn't even think about that. uh Dear archive, I'd really like a puppy for Christmas, can you?
Brian (41:00)
let's be clear, you don't need to mail it to her. She just gets it instantly. So you just have seventeen-year-old wizard apprentices asking her, you know, Dear Archive help me on my homework. So I think it's sort of uh one of those things where and I'm I'm being half serious, but
This is the kind of information that's just a little bit too important to tell people who don't need to know. It's not a secret, but unless you have a reason to know about it, nobody's gonna bring it up. And if you go looking for it, it might be kind of hard to find.
Adam "Bridger" Ruzzo (41:33)
Exactly right. Now,
Kincaid proves his legitimacy. Ivy comes down, he gives he winds up having a little conversation with what's your name? You have to have a name. He gives her a name. And then she starts this exposition about what is the archive? Because Harry doesn't know, so he needs to be informed. But if you are an astute reader, you may have noticed that there are some contradictions between the exposition given in this chapter and
In small favor when Harry and Lucio are discussing the archive again, and we get a rehash of some of these same stories and details about the archive, but we get differences. So, Brian, I'm gonna first start with this quote: I hold the accumulated memories of a thousand generations of mankind. I take in all that is written and spoken. I study, I learn. That is my purpose, to procure and preserve knowledge.
Unquote. Now, the important bit here is when she says, I take in all that is written and spoken. That is from death masks. What we get in small favor is when Harry says, quote, The archive is a magic so complex that it's practically alive and it just knows.
Anything that gets printed or written down, the archive knows. Unquote. Now, Brian, do you think it's a mistake or just left off the page but still true that he says only things that get written down are things she automatically knows. Whereas in this chapter, she takes in all that is written and spoken.
Brian (43:07)
So I think that with all of the things we're gonna go over here, it's important to kind of give two answers to it. And one is okay, so if this isn't a retcon by Jim, if he didn't change it, what does it mean? And I think there's only two sensible ways to interpret this. Either one, Ivy takes in all that is written and spoken.
Parentheses around her. That is, Ivy has a perfect memory of everything that has been written and also everything that's been said in her presence.
Adam "Bridger" Ruzzo (43:42)
Mm.
Brian (43:43)
Not necessarily everything that's been said by everyone, everywhere.
Adam "Bridger" Ruzzo (43:45)
Right. Wa the one applies to everything, the other is just an identity memory.
Brian (43:50)
Right. Another possibility is that the archive actually does have access to all spoken information. And when I mean they say the archive is a thousand generations old. To put this in perspective, we're thinking like eighteen thousand BC. That's
Adam "Bridger" Ruzzo (44:07)
Yeah.
Brian (44:08)
what we're talking about. So eighteen thousand BC is before the existence of civilization. It is
before the Middle Stone Age. It might even be before the Paleolithic era. This is really, really early human history. Like we're talking about the dawn of Homo sapiens kind I mean, I don't wanna this can get really complicated, so I don't want to throw around too many things because I think a lot of people would say the year like 5000's the dawn of Homo sapiens.
But this is so far into prehistory that it's not even properly characterized as prehistory. This is still paleontology. So the archive exists at a time where the human population is so much smaller, it's difficult to comprehend. And maybe when the archive was constructed, since there was no writing, the archive did just record everything that was spoken.
Adam "Bridger" Ruzzo (45:08)
Yeah.
Brian (45:08)
And then,
you know, ten thousand years later we invent writing and hey, that's a lot better. Now I'm gonna be a record of everything that's written, because actually there's too many people and I can't sort the wheat from the chaff with the spoken stuff. There's just too many inconsequential things being said. But if I only focus on the written word, the only things that get written down are important. In fact, we'll talk about this later, but it might be the case that the archive needs to make some other change.
Because right now she has access to all things that are written, including the internet, which is very unfortunate.
Adam "Bridger" Ruzzo (45:44)
uh Yeah, very unfortunate. Also fortunate, but also unfortunate. So I think it's pretty clear that this is a retcon for one reason, very specifically. You get that scene in small favor when Harry realizes oh, she is going to have to withstand this torture that's they're putting onto her. And she doesn't necessarily it's like intellectually, she knows.
Someone's probably coming to help her, but she doesn't know that, like in here, like in her heart, kind of a thing. And then he's like, Oh, wait a minute. And he writes down, Ivy, we're coming for you. You're not alone. Don't give up. We're coming for you from Harry. Like something like that. I don't know the exact wording. But the fact he had to write it down in that scene, and nobody goes, You didn't have to do that. We just talked about it. We're coming for she knows, right?
Suggest that it has to be a retcon.
Brian (46:41)
Yes, I think that's right. I and I also think that the original thing that we stated, that it's all that is written and spoken in her presence, must be true, unless we take it as an even bigger retcon. Because as it stands, the archive very, very, very clearly predates writing.
Adam "Bridger" Ruzzo (46:58)
Yeah, Alright, so the next contradiction here, Brian, is quote My mother passed it on to me as I was born.
Just as she received it when she was born, unquote. That's from Death Masks. And it implies that as soon as the child of the archive is born, they become the next archive immediately. And here's what we get in Death Masks from Lucio, quote: The archive has been around for a long time, always passed down in family line, mother to daughter. Usually the archive is inherited by a woman when she's in her early to mid-thirties, when her mother dies.
and after she's given birth to her own daughter, unquote. So this directly implies that the archive is not inherited at birth, but rather when the previous parent dies, as opposed to Ivy stating in this chapter that it happens when they're born.
Brian (47:49)
Yeah, the I the way that Ivy describes it, you get to have your own independent non-archive life when you're older, and the way Lucio says
Adam "Bridger" Ruzzo (47:58)
That's the way Lucio disguised.
Brian (47:59)
it is the exact opposite. You get to have your own independent life not as the archive when you're younger. So it's a direct opposition to each other. Now I think one way square this is that Ivy
In this scene, as the six-year-old girl, actually doesn't have the intellectual capacity to make sense of all of the memories she possesses. So, for example, the fact that Ivy's mother died, and that Ivy has the memory of her mother killing herself as the archive in her head.
means that it's all very painful for her. And she might be, because of the trauma, misremembering this, or letting this file become a little bit corrupted, or just kind of, putting it away. And she's not speaking as the archive here. She's just speaking as what she remembers, you know, the archive knows. Or her what's easy for her to say that the archive knows.
That what Ivy is saying here is something like a lie to protect herself and to keep from f her from explaining something painful to her. The other possibility is of course that Jim just changed it because the other way, the way that Lucho explains it, is significantly it's much more tragic that Ivy's in the position she's in.
Adam "Bridger" Ruzzo (49:23)
Yes, and we know that Jim probably would err on the side of more tragic. The other thing that this does is connect to the next contradiction, and it goes like this. Again, death masks first, quote. My mother is dead, wizard. Not dead technically, but all that she knew and was came into me. She became an empty cup, a persistent vegetative state. She's free of it.
she certainly isn't alive in the most vital sense. Unquote. We get that in Death Masks, and again, in small favor, we get this from Lucio, quote: Her grandmother was killed in a freak accident, an automobile crash, I believe. Her mother was a seventeen-year-old girl who was in love and pregnant. She hated her mother for dying and cursing her to carry the archive when she wanted to have her own life, and she hated the child for having a lifetime of freedom ahead of her.
Ivy's mother killed herself rather than carry the archive. Unquote. So here we have a direct contradiction. Ivy says, My mother turned into a vegetative state, a husk, technically alive, but not in any sense that matters, because all that she was flowed into me. Whereas Lucio straight up says, No, sh that she killed herself because she hated being the archive at such a young age. So to me
This one's very hard to square, Brian. How how can we say if this isn't a retcon? How does it make sense?
Brian (50:49)
Right. I mean, you're right about being a hard to square, Adam, because taken together with the other statement that we went over, Ivy is saying when the archive has a child, they pass the archive on to that child the moment she is born, and they become a vegetable with their entire essence flowing into the child.
Adam "Bridger" Ruzzo (51:11)
Right.
Brian (51:11)
Lucio describes it as the archive
only passes when the holder of the archive's mortal life ends. So in order for Ivy to become the archive, her mother, while she was the archive, had to commit suicide.
So I think there's a couple different slight variants of how to wreck on this, but they all orbit around the same idea, which is that Ivy is again kind of lying because it's too painful for her to kind of talk about the truth. Or, and this is something that's a little bit different for this one. I mean, we spoke about this a little bit before the show, Adam. It sounds like from what Lucio is saying that.
you know, freak accident. Sounds like somebody's trying to kill the archive.
Adam "Bridger" Ruzzo (51:58)
Yeah, I actually I think this adds this this version is so much better and more mysterious and interesting, and I think that's the reason Jim decided, you know what? I'm gonna go ahead and go with the archive because what kind of sickos are gonna stand around and notice these small differences that I'm putting in here? uh
Brian (52:15)
Right. But but
if you take it as somebody's trying to kill the archive, well then the reason why Ivy is not telling Harry the truth here is because they've started to be very careful about who knows about the true nature of the archive. Because
Adam "Bridger" Ruzzo (52:36)
That's a good point.
Brian (52:38)
for the next
20 years or so. I mean, realistically for the next 10 years, but you know, hopefully for the next 20 years or so. Ivy's it. If you do get to her, game set match.
Adam "Bridger" Ruzzo (52:51)
Yeah.
Brian (52:51)
So it might behoove her to sew a little misinformation just so people don't know how to come at her. I mean, we're literally the next time we see her, when we're finding out all this information from Lucio, we're gonna see somebody coming right at the archive.
Adam "Bridger" Ruzzo (53:06)
Yeah. And who knows? In another book we might get another version of this story. And it's gonna be like the Joker from Batman. Every time he tells you his story about how he got his scars, it's different, right? It could very well be.
Brian (53:16)
You wanna know how I got this construct inside my head?
My father. Yeah.
Adam "Bridger" Ruzzo (53:21)
Yeah, exactly.
I'll throw one more piece on top of this, right? We've got the automobile crash that killed Ivy's grandmother, right? A freak accident, she says. And then her mother couldn't take the burden of the archive, and she had resented her daughter for having a whole life ahead of her, and so she took her own life. It's a good story, but what if you have someone directly, diametrically opposed to the archive? Like, I don't know.
A cult to the old ones that doesn't want it to exist anymore, right? And you say, okay, the freak accident with the car, maybe that was arranged. But how could they arrange a suicide? Well, we see it in White Knight, right? They get a skavus to go after and successfully kill the archive's mother, and the only thing they missed is they didn't get Ivy in the process. Maybe they tried and failed and
And maybe that cult got wiped out as a result because the protectors of the archive at the time managed to make it happen. But boy, that's a story I want to know more about. It's see it's hinted there. I think there's more to it.
Brian (54:28)
Yeah, I mean, you know, Jim could do something like he could have, you know, 'cause Scavis Whitecourt vampire suicide, right? He could have one set of white court vampires kind of working with, right, this organization.
Adam "Bridger" Ruzzo (54:43)
Mm.
Brian (54:44)
And and like maybe some because white court vampire is backstabby, another set is kind of working against them, right? And the archive line of all female, extremely powerful, magical, constructs.
It would be cool to oppose them with some kind of, you know, sisterhood. Like that was involved with ancient, you know, evil, like the like a
a Stygian sisterhood, which is exactly the name of the organization in backup that Thomas.
Is working against in the Oblivion War alongside
Adam "Bridger" Ruzzo (55:19)
Yeah.
Brian (55:20)
Lara. So I totally think that's possible, Adam. And I'm not saying it's necessarily the Stygian sisterhood, but Jim is seeding ideas like that in this world. The Oblivion War is a deadly conflict. I think, though, there is an another version of this that's avoiding a retcon, which is that Lucio knows the story.
Of the archive's mother killing herself.
that the archive's pregnant mother killed herself.
So a different version of this, which is ic o extremely tragic and why I think Jim could do it this way, is that the archives mother tried to kill herself. And you know, maybe she didn't do a good job. Maybe there was somebody there who knew that they had to save the fetus inside her. Maybe she was kept alive.
In a persistent vegetative state, so that Ivy could be born, and that what Ivy says, all that she knew came into me, she became an empty cup, a persistent vegetative state. That's all correct. It's just sort of said in an order that implies something that kind of slides over the really gory details.
Adam "Bridger" Ruzzo (56:34)
Yeah,
it's it's an anomaly because of the attempted suicide that didn't quite succeed, that resulted in okay, the the archive has to pass in a different way than normal. Okay, I could buy that, yeah. Okay. So those are the sort of contradictions. I think it's much easier to read this at least going forward, to assume all of the things said in small favor take precedence. Would you say that's
Brian (56:57)
Yes,
Adam "Bridger" Ruzzo (56:58)
true?
Brian (56:58)
I absolutely agree with that. And I think frankly, despite us trying to justify how they might not be retcons, I think it's simpler if you just assume on page it's a retcon. You can invent backstory that does make some of these things work, but Jim has not engaged with any of that. So Occam's razor, right now, it's a retcon. But Adam, there's one more contradiction.
Or possible contradiction. Harry's wards go nuts when the archive rolls up. Which makes sense. Harry later compares her to senior council members and fairy queens. She's a badass little girl.
But then how can she use electronics? Like she can't reach the pedals of the car. That's the only reason she can't drive a modern automobile. It's not about her magic.
Adam "Bridger" Ruzzo (57:52)
But She's
riding around in the car with Kincaid and it's not breaking down. And you'd think they would need a Model T if we look at the
Brian (58:00)
Right.
Adam "Bridger" Ruzzo (58:00)
power curve, right? Harry is pretty dang strong. He can do like a sixties Beatle. And then we get the nineteen thirty-nine version from Ebenezer. And I mean, we'd need to go all the way back to a Model T or earlier in order to make
Brian (58:14)
Yeah, it's a horse
and buggy. Kincaid is yeah, exactly. Right, exactly, yes.
Adam "Bridger" Ruzzo (58:16)
Horse and Bucky uh The horse almost breaks down if you get one that's too that's
too modern. So the the there's a couple different ways to make this make sense. And one is that, okay, she's just way better at suppressing her magic than Harry is. I mean, she's got thousands of potential lifetimes of practice using magic. It completely makes sense that she would be able to simultaneously suppress the Murphy field and
and use her magic as needed to keep tabs around her, shields up, whatever it is. That's possible because she's just so much better at at it than anybody else on the planet.
Brian (58:53)
Yeah, the archive is on the level of the sufficiently advanced to Merlin magic on demon reach.
Adam "Bridger" Ruzzo (58:59)
Yes.
Brian (59:00)
She's just doing stuff that other wizards can't even conceive of as being possible every morning before breakfast. That's totally, totally pop. I mean, we see Harry suppress his Murphyionic field in the beginning of this book. They can do it. It's just Ivy can do it in granular and perfect ways that don't even occur to Dresden. But Adam.
I think the answer is simpler than that. Marcone can still use technology when he's got Nam Shil's coin and he throws around some pretty impressive sorcery. If you've
Adam "Bridger" Ruzzo (59:30)
And we know Molly
is still able to use a cell phone now that she's a fairy queen.
Brian (59:35)
And fairy
queens, I will grant you, are a little bit different than Denarians, because a denarian can put down the coin in a way that Molly kind of can't. You know, it's a part of her in a way that maybe is more inseparable. But if you've got a construct in your head, and the construct is the thing that's magic, then no Murphyonic field. The contradictions
Adam "Bridger" Ruzzo (59:58)
Yeah.
Brian (59:59)
are between the inconstancy of humans and
And the expression of magic, the archive, the construct doesn't have to deal with that in constancy.
Adam "Bridger" Ruzzo (1:00:08)
Yeah, it may be that it's drawing from the same source as human magic, but it just because of the way it's using it, it doesn't generate a Murphyionic field, or it's its own separate source of magic that doesn't necessarily interact with mortal magic other than use the same mechanisms, but from a different source, in the same way that Denarians you can use Hellfire and
And that doesn't necessarily affect technology or Molly uses her cell phone and because she's not operating on mortal magic anymore, that still works. So those are all possibilities.
Brian (1:00:43)
I think it's really important to mention that Ivy is the archive, but as far as we can tell, this is not exactly the same thing as Ivy, the person, is the archive, the position, and the position comes with these powers and abilities. Ivy is a person.
Who is separate from the archive. And every other archive, basically, has had an independent life as a separate person from the archive before they've become the archive. Ivy's weird in that she's never not been the archive. but the
Adam "Bridger" Ruzzo (1:01:23)
Right.
Brian (1:01:23)
reason why that's so important for a discussion of magic or a discussion of, the archive's capabilities or just how Ivy thinks about the world is that as the archive,
She has access to knowledge and and intellectual capabilities and magical capabilities that are far beyond any normal person. But it's still running on the hardware of a six-year-old girl who has her own six-year-old girl personality and her own six-year-old girl ideas. And yes, can be way, way wiser and way weirder than any six-year-old anyone's ever actually met.
But still has some fundamental things about her that the archive can't change because the archive isn't precisely her. They're two separate things that are sharing one existence.
Adam "Bridger" Ruzzo (1:02:17)
Right.
They're definitely separate, but fused at the same time, because Harry even mentions in small favor several times, like they're not attacking the archive, they're attacking Ivy, the child, when they're trying to get Kincaid so that they can force her out. And in this chapter, as extra proof to exactly what you're saying, when Mr. shows up, Ivy looks down and says, Kiddie, and in immediately kneels down to pet Mister
And that's just not something that like a thousand year old consciousness would do. It's fused to a six year old consciousness.
Brian (1:02:53)
Yes, all of Ivy's stuff, like watching the otters, petting the kitty, it's really, really cute on page. I mean, it's adorable. Ivy is adorable. God, she's like she's such a cool little girl. But it's also, if you think about it, from being in that head, like really messed up. Like Ivy has to sort of express a bunch of ideas that basically like a thousand grandmothers.
Are like telling her what to say, you for a while. And then the grandmothers sometimes have to just like relinquish control because the six-year-old doesn't have the attention span to keep listening because there's a kitty. And
Adam "Bridger" Ruzzo (1:03:31)
Yeah, yeah.
Brian (1:03:32)
that's like a really that that internal not monologue, not even dialogue, that internal cacophony is just her entire existence. That's why it makes a lot more sense if the archive passes to people.
Not like Ivy says when they're first born, but when they've got a lot of life experience and they can deal with it.
Adam "Bridger" Ruzzo (1:03:52)
And it adds that extra layer we get in small favor where Lucio is very worried about the stability of this archive because it has always been the archive and it's never had its own childhood and its own time to build its own identity as Ivy in this case. So we'll we're gonna talk more about that when we get there.
That about wraps up our discussion of chapter 10. The last chapter that we're gonna talk about today is chapter 11. It's a very short chapter, and there's not a lot that happens in here that's worth going over. Harry calls Vincent to provide a quick update. And the only thing I want to point out is just remember, Vincent is actually Cassius. And so when Harry says, Yeah, I got a lead that says the shroud might be down by the marina. So I'm gonna check it out. No, don't worry about it. I'll let you know if there's anything there.
That is what dooms Francesca to be killed by Deirdre in the next set of chapters. It's kinda tragic.
Brian (1:04:48)
If you think of Anna Valmont in this book as kind of being that ungrateful bitch, just realize she's kinda right. The only reason her friends die is because Dresden comes looking.
Adam "Bridger" Ruzzo (1:05:02)
And he's not clever enough to see through Father Vincent. Of course, give him the benefit of the doubt. I mean, Father Vincent is being portrayed by somebody with hundreds, if not thousands, of years of duplication of doppelgangering. I don't know what skill you'd call that. Mimicry. So he's playing against a a stacked deck is what I'm trying to say.
Brian (1:05:24)
And then Harry at the very end of the chapter makes that phone call for Michael and instead has to leave a message with charity. Now, Adam, our next episode will be for patrons. It is Bigfoot on Campus Part One.
Adam "Bridger" Ruzzo (1:05:40)
That's right, the feet
are so big we had to do two parts.
Brian (1:05:44)
Yeah, Bigfoot the third part un and then we'll get to you know three point two in the future.
but we had a question for Bob this week,
Bob couldn't make it. I called him this time and he just said boats and boobs to me over and over again. What does that even mean?
Adam "Bridger" Ruzzo (1:06:04)
Did he just discover that houseboats exist and have windows that aren't normally closed?
Brian (1:06:09)
I don't know, but we had a question for Bob and it was anyway, what'll happen the next time that Harry meets Ivy? So we went and asked Reddit and you guys had, my god, a lot of responses.
Adam "Bridger" Ruzzo (1:06:21)
First, we have Cole Rains reminding us about the microfiction goodbye. Quote, she was upset enough that she fired Kincaid. I feel like that says a lot about how she feels about it, unquote. For those of you who are not uh aware, there were several microfictions that were posted to Jim Butcher's website. You can still find them on his website if you search for
Dresden Files Microfiction. You'll probably find several links that'll take you there. I think there were five in total, and they were all very, very short. This one was Kincaid just hanging up the phone with Dresden right after he has called during changes to contract his own assassination. And Kincaid puts in the information into his computer to chart a course to
Chicago, he gets his plane tickets, he arranges for hardware to be sent there, and as he walks out the door, Ivy is standing there, tears streaming down her eyes. She knows what he's about to do.
Brian (1:07:25)
Yeah. And she says
In the chest, Kincaid, not the head, the chest. Because Ivy is the only reason
Mab and Demon Reach and Benea are able to have enough Harry left to keep him mostly alive.
Adam "Bridger" Ruzzo (1:07:43)
Yeah, and then Kincaid goes and thinks, Ugh, you're not supposed to shoot people in the chest. I can shoot him in the head. That's a better thing. But she says, in the chest or face me. And Kincaid's like, I'd rather take a pissed off Dresden than a pissed off archive, so I'm gonna shoot him in the chest. And then he says, I'll be back in two days, and this is where we get the most applicable piece of information to what we're talking about now. She says, Kincaid.
He's my only other friend. My feet reach the pedals now. Your services are no longer required. That's it. That's basically the end. She dismisses him from her service, apparently because of what he is about to do. And you have to imagine if she's furious at him for taking the contract, she must be at least a little angry or disappointed at Harry for meeting it out in the first place.
Brian (1:08:37)
Yeah, now introvert crew, when we asked this question, brought us a useful word of Jim that we should use to inform this discussion. So the question in that is asked in this word of Jim that that he's bringing up is uh will Harry not calling Ivy since his return from being uh also mostly dead come to bite him in the ass
Since he is a father figure to her and seems to simply have forgotten to contact her for about three years. And Jim says, Ivy sees Harry more as a friend. She is more concerned about him. Her anger is directed at Kincaid. Ivy could pick up the telephone at any time, but as the archive, she does have a different scale of time than normal people. She basically can read everybody's mail anyway. She's a pretty creepy kid. And then the audience laughs.
And the reason why I we want to bring up this word of Jim is because this seems to undercut the whole premise of this question. Okay, Ivy's mad at Kincaid. What's gonna happen the next time she and Dresden hang out? She's gonna go, hey man, how you doing? You know, last time I kind of quasi interacted with you, you were suicidal. So, that's one possible reading of you know what's gonna happen vis-a-vis what we're asking.
But I think something that we need to sort of contextualize this discussion with is that Jim is right in saying that Harry is more of a friend than a father figure.
Adam "Bridger" Ruzzo (1:10:03)
Mm-hmm.
Brian (1:10:03)
But
The archive only has two friends.
Adam "Bridger" Ruzzo (1:10:06)
Yeah, and that I think does put it into a context. now before we go on to answer the question, I do want to address one thing in this specific word of Jim. Why do you think she's more mad at Kincaid than at Harry? Should he have not taken the contract?
Brian (1:10:22)
Yeah, that is something that sort of suggests that she's handling this situation irrationally. Not as the archive, but as the girl. Because if Kincaid says no, Harry would just contact somebody else. I mean, he's doing this. He's setting it up so that he dies when the mission is over.
And then he's having Molly erase his memory of it. Like that's what's gonna happen here. The fact that Kin Kincaid says yes, which Dresden is banking on, makes things a lot easier for him. But Dresden is doing his damnedest to get out of being the winter knight. In fact, maybe you can argue the only reason he survives is because it is Kincaid, and the archive can tell him what to do. So Harry's the one who created this whole situation.
Shouldn't she rationally be more angry at him? And I think it's just that we could assume the archive, maybe on a very visceral level.
Understands why Dresden is doing what he's doing. I mean, the archive has her own mother living in her head. Somebody who, arguably did the same thing but worse. Kincaid actually can say no. And not only could Kincaid say no, Kincaid could go to Chicago to shoot anybody who does try to kill Dresden.
Adam "Bridger" Ruzzo (1:11:42)
Yeah.
The piece of this that makes the most sense to me is that Dresden is the victim here. He's a victim of his own situation. So she's cutting him some slack. Whereas Kincaid choosing to enable this suicide attempt is a choice that she can't seem to forgive.
Whereas maybe she can forgive Harry for trying to protect others from a evil version of himself, even if she may know that that's not what would have happened.
Brian (1:12:13)
Yeah, and I think it's really important to contextualize that too. Because Ivy can definitely understand that, not just because, you know, her mother was given a supernatural construct that messes with her ability to act as herself and then killed herself and Ivy's intimately familiar with that instinct, and that's basically what Dresden is doing, but also because Ivy herself is someone
Whose life is very complicated because she has to be the archive and not just a little girl. So she might sympathize with Dresden not wanting to be the winter knight. But that also might be a reason why, though she's not angry at Dresden exactly, she could have some very complicated emotions towards him. Especially because, Adam, I don't think it's a coincidence that the archive's
Only two friends are older men who have or do protect her. It's because part of being the archive is fundamentally not treating other people like they're your equal because you do know better than they do. You do have to be the wise mature adult in the room every time. And the only person that Ivy.
Doesn't feel weird being a kid around, is Kincaid, who's known her since before her feet reached the pedals, and is Dresden, who gave her her name and therefore, and we talk about the ways that starborn name things as being specifically perhaps important, gave her her name and therefore to a certain extent an identity, and
literally saved her from a fate worse than death by like a lot. Because if she became a Denarian, that would be an inescapable series of horrors.
Adam "Bridger" Ruzzo (1:14:05)
Yeah. So now let's address the question itself. What happens when Ivy meets Harry, not just in passing in peace talks, but in a personal interaction? How does she react to seeing him again? And on the one hand, you got some people that answered, it's no big deal. Introvert crew fell on this side and basically kind of addressed that she's probably already worked through all of her drama and based on
that Jim interview, he seems to imply that she's fine with it at this point, that she's had thousands of lifetimes of grief and forgiveness and understanding and intellectually has able to come to the conclusion that like, okay, his problem is his problem. I don't need to make it my problem. I'll forgive him because what is it, bitterness is a poison you give yourself, hoping that someone else will will get hurt. That kind of a thing. So that's the one side of it. But
There were quite a few people that suggested that there will probably be some drama.
Brian (1:15:03)
Yeah, and the answer that it's no big deal was pretty popular. And I'll also say, even some of the pieces of evidence that we're gonna talk about on the other side, like Ivy seeming to pointedly not talk to Dresden during peace talks, could go the other way as well. Dresden sees over the crowd pretty easily. Maybe Dresden saw Ivy and she didn't really see him, and she's not avoiding him at all. She's just very, very important and very, very busy.
And she'd love to talk to him. Just the moment hasn't arrived yet. She's got a lot to do. But there's also reasons why I think the answers there will be drama have some legs. Eloquos raptor comes down on the side of it won't be pleasant. They have a nice history, but I'm sure there's plenty of resentment over Dresden's attempted suicide that won't be addressed.
And come out in a general prickliness. Not to mention, Dresden himself is a worse man now when they met. Much more ruthless. Much more a man who considers leadership and power to be something that requires extreme violence to protect. Someone who no longer sees such a problem with breaking the first law, who believes that protecting others.
Requires a little shedding of one's own soul on the blades of atrocity and moral injury. It's a sad thing, and one that Ivy is aware of happening a thousand, thousand times over. Now that it's happening to Dresden, she isn't going to be thrilled. And while she liked the man he was.
She will treat him according to the man he is now. Hoof
Adam "Bridger" Ruzzo (1:16:52)
Yeah, that one is crazy. And I hadn't thought about that. That like, he is more ruthless, more willing to deal with problems in a way that the old Dresden would have given, oh no, let's let's give more chan like you like you point out all the time in Full Moon, where he just let Roger go.
That's a threat that you shouldn't just leave behind you, but he just did, and that's not something the winter knight would necessarily do.
Brian (1:17:21)
Yeah, and I think part of what you have to read into what Elequosaraptor is saying is, Ivy's a teenage girl. So her interpretation of what Dresden's doing doesn't have to, come out in her grandmotherly walking over and being like, you know, with my accumulated wisdom, young man, I need you to know that you're going down the wrong path. She might just be like
Annoyed and resentful the way that a fifteen or sixteen
Adam "Bridger" Ruzzo (1:17:49)
Yeah?
Brian (1:17:49)
or seventeen year old girl could be annoyed or resentful.
Adam "Bridger" Ruzzo (1:17:53)
Yeah, absolutely. Now Powder Kager gave us another explanation. He makes a very interesting connection that might explain her anger towards Harry if it does exist. Quote, Dresden did more than just give her a name. He gave her a sense of self divorced from her mantle's power. Then when Harry became the Winter Knight, he made plans to have himself killed because he didn't believe he'd be any different from the previous Winter Knights.
So when it was his ass on the line, his actions showed that he didn't actually believe in what he had done for Ivy. Or at least that's what Ivy's pr thought process might be. Add to that the paranormal muckety muck that the to the very real hurt of a friend trying to kill themselves, and you've got a teenage girl with some very confusing and hurtful feelings and a clear target for that angst, unquote. I had never made that connection, Brian, that Harry tried to.
give her an identity separate from her mantle and say this is possible. But then in killing himself, he's stating the opposite. It's not possible to be separate from this mantle of the winter night. I would rather die than make that happen. That might be saying something about what what she is.
Brian (1:19:03)
Yeah, I mean look, that's not very far fetched. Jim already wrote that. Those very words, with slight differences, come out of Thomas's mouth right after Harry comes back. Oh, you became a predator and you thought you should kill yourself because what's worse than being a predator? Gee, thanks, Lil Bro. I feel great about that. You
Adam "Bridger" Ruzzo (1:19:26)
Yeah.
Brian (1:19:27)
know? And uh as the archive, yes, she is.
Wiser than Thomas in certain ways, she's also in other ways less experienced than he is, and perhaps more tender. I think that one way to characterize what Harry is towards the archive, and I don't think this is like necessarily the best way or a perfect way, but Cryptid Grimnoir in the thread said he's like a godfather to her. He named her.
And when Kincaid couldn't do it, he protected her. And someone you have that kind of relationship with, kind of disavowing the very sort of being that you are, yeah, that would be very painful, even if you weren't angry at them. Looking at them would bring up a lot of painful memories and thoughts and ideas. So maybe Ivy is not mad at Dresden.
But maybe the reason why she doesn't find the six foot nine wizard in peace talks and go speak to him is because she's hurt.
Adam "Bridger" Ruzzo (1:20:32)
Yeah. Now, Rob nobody answered the question more directly. Not just would she be angry or not, but what would she do as a result of that? And said she would ask him not to call her Ivy anymore. Oh boy, that would be a bit of a gut check. But I could totally see it happening because, she's getting more mature and she might realize the same thing that Lucio's realizing, that like
This is an unstable situation for the construct, and I need to be more mature and I need to be more o aware of what I am and I can't have people calling me by pet names and getting attached. Like that's the worst that could happen. After all, look what happened when the person I was attached to tried to kill themselves. It bothered me this much. So I'm just gonna get rid of all attachments. Don't call me Ivy anymore. That would hurt my heart, and therefore Jim is probably gonna do it.
Brian (1:21:22)
Well, that one I really like because it would be her trying to do effectively what Harry did, that is, reject being a person, being herself, and in her case because she's too responsible to destroy the archive, just fully embracing that that's what she is, trying to divorce herself from her own humanity.
That's really extreme, honestly. I think that it's definitely within the realm of possibility, and I think I remember Rob Nobody making that prediction before Peace Talks came out. I definitely could see it, but if it happens, that might be the kind of thing that we don't find out about until the bat, because actually it's a whole big deal and it's the reason why the archive isn't doing something that maybe we would normally expect her to do.
Adam "Bridger" Ruzzo (1:22:13)
Yeah, I absolutely could see that too.
Brian (1:22:15)
So
Adam, let me just ask before we uh wrap this up, what's your answer?
Adam "Bridger" Ruzzo (1:22:19)
I think she is going to forgive him the next time they meet.
Brian (1:22:25)
That there is something there, Yeah.
Adam "Bridger" Ruzzo (1:22:26)
There's someth she is angry
and she's going to use that opportunity to like officially say, I forgive you for leaving me when you were one of
Brian (1:22:35)
Right.
Adam "Bridger" Ruzzo (1:22:36)
my only friends and it's gonna be a gut check to him, like, man, another thing I didn't think about before I tried to kill myself was all the people I was leaving behind, including her. I think that's gonna like the like they're they're going to if she comes back and they have a conversation, it's because
She's needed for the plot somehow. And I think Jim's not gonna make her relationship with him to be really problematic to like last an entire book. They're gonna get it out of the way in the first scene. That's my prediction. If she comes back.
Brian (1:23:09)
Yeah, I agree completely, just with a little bit of a different spin on it. Dresden is a father to a daughter now. I think the next time that he ends up seeing Ivy, Dresden is going to try to treat her like a kid.
Adam "Bridger" Ruzzo (1:23:25)
And that's not gonna work so well.
Brian (1:23:27)
And Ivy is gonna fire back with something along the lines of, Dresden, I've had two people in my life who did things that parents do for me. One of them is Kincaid, and you hired him to kill the other one. So I don't really need you to try to, tell me what to do anymore, or tell me how to be, or pass on your wisdom, or whatever a a cherbic bitter thing.
She's gonna throw at him to check him from, being the thing that wizards can sometimes be, arrogant and egotistical and thinking that they know better. And I don't think that that's gonna be her saying, I don't like you anymore, we're not friends. I think that's gonna be her letting out something that's been weighing on her for a while. And after that scene's over, they're going to get over it. It's going to be okay.
But it'll come out with something like that. It'll be a something that she uses to show Harry the negative consequences of his actions when he doesn't think of other people.
Adam "Bridger" Ruzzo (1:24:27)
All right, that's gonna wrap it up here for us. Brian, we're going to be back next time on Death Masks 4. That's in two weeks, by the way, where we're gonna talk about the étranger and the talk between Susan and Harry, where she finally breaks it off with him.
Brian (1:24:44)
Yeah, we can finally get to the long awaited Dresden discussions of what shampoo gives you metal blade hair.
Adam "Bridger" Ruzzo (1:24:51)
Absolutely. We'll see you guys then.
Creators and Guests
